Where or what to eat in Elmira, New York

Where to eat in Elmira, New York

Friday, September 6, 2013

Fat Cats Brooklyn Deli

Their "Bensonhurst." Just look at the perfection
in the slices!
Fat Cats Brooklyn Deli, 1002 Walnut Street, 607-368-3790. We have a winner. The food is delicious. Top quality. There is something to be said for merchants who take great pride in their products and service. Thank you for moving to Elmira. Sandwiches are truly a work of art. The guy making the sandwiches is a "sandwich artist." He cuts the most perfect slices of meat we have ever seen. Huge sandwiches. It took two of us to eat a "Bensonhurst." "Boro Park" is great, too. Like the "Vickster" also. Last visit 9/5/2013 with 2 guests - takeout. Lunch only. One person makes sandwiches one at a time so expect to wait for your perfect sandwich. Don't worry - it's a nice wait. In the many times we have reviewed this restaurant the food has been consistently good.

4 STARS - Easily, the best sandwiches in Elmira

 ** Food 10 out of 10 **
** Service 10 out of 10 **
**Cleanliness 10 out of 10**
Ambience 9.5 out of 10
Value 9.5 out of 10
Total score 49 out of 50 points

Fat Cats Brooklyn Deli on Urbanspoon


  1. Their "Bensonhurst” seems so delicious huh! Also it does gain a nice review, this is indeed nice outlook for customers. Customer's would definitely go back for more!

    Flavors of New York

  2. Food was amazing! I would recommend the Papa Cat hero....delicious! I have half left for lunch tomorrow, yum.

  3. Great subs, huge portions, good prices, and phenomenal service! I'll be back for sure!

  4. I get the grilled Reuben. Worth the wait for perfection. Grew up in NYC with family in Brooklyn. So yummmmy.

  5. Amazing food, and great people! We are always satisfied! :):)


Leave your comment.....