Where or what to eat in Elmira, New York

Where to eat in Elmira, New York

Thursday, August 1, 2013


Reuben sandwich - dry and tough
Horigan's365 Davis Street - see map on right for directions. AMERICAN-IRISH, great food - which is great for Elmira, all kinds of daily specials, hey, you never know what it will be - but it will be good. Our last visit was 7/30/2013 with 4 guests - lunch. We regret to report that this was our THIRD "less than stellar" visit to Horigan's this summer. Usually, the food is exceptional, but all times our  Reuben and French Dip sandwiches were dry, tough, tasteless, and a disappointment. They are usually our favorites. The seafood chowder and cole slaw were excellent. We'll go back regardless of these 3 occurrences.  $ - $$. In the many times we have reviewed this restaurant the food has USUALLY been consistently good. Hoping that the last 3 visits were just a fluke.

Food 6 out of 10
Service 7 out of 10
Cleanliness 8 out of 10
Ambience 9 out of 10
Value 9 out of 10
Total score 39 out of 50 points

Horigan's Tavern on Urbanspoon

1 comment:

  1. Best cheesesteak in elmira?? Haha! Not even the best one on Davis St. Anyway, the service was horrible the night we went. Had tickets to a show, our food took over 60 MINUTES from the time we ordered. Meanwhile, well known locals (DA, lawyers) came in AFTER us and were served before us. Close to showtime I went to the bar to say we would pay for the appetizers/drinks, but we've waited too long and didn't want to be late....at which point the owner said "the show doesn't start until 7 (it was 6:40) you have time", 3 minutes later our food came out completely cold! Haven't gone back since.


Leave your comment.....